Narrative:

In descent to memphis on ujm arrival, ZME issued a crossing restr at ujm VOR to cross at 12000 ft. We were in the descent to FL240, passing through FL300 at 30 DME southwest of ujm, when this crossing was issued. We initiated descent to an increase of 4000 FPM descent, 2:1 for us on profile descent. We extended the speed brakes also at FL200. I informed ATC that we were unable to cross ujm at 12000 ft, tailwind component was 80 KTS. ZME abruptly vectored us off inbound radial and offered remarks as to why we couldn't cross it as everyone else was. I informed him we had done everything possible. Supplemental information from acn 536747: controller gave a crossing restr that required excessive descent rates with idle power, full speed brakes and 5000-6000 FPM rates. When we called to tell him we would miss the restr by 2000 ft, he became argumentative about why we couldn't make the restr. We informed him about winds 220 degrees, 80 KTS. Perhaps an earlier descent or use of the published altitude restrs on the arrival would have prevented the discussion.

Google
 

Original NASA ASRS Text

Title: A DSNDING DC9 FAILS TO MAKE THE ASSIGNED ALT XING RESTR AT UJM VOR SW OF MEM, TN.

Narrative: IN DSCNT TO MEMPHIS ON UJM ARR, ZME ISSUED A XING RESTR AT UJM VOR TO CROSS AT 12000 FT. WE WERE IN THE DSCNT TO FL240, PASSING THROUGH FL300 AT 30 DME SW OF UJM, WHEN THIS XING WAS ISSUED. WE INITIATED DSCNT TO AN INCREASE OF 4000 FPM DSCNT, 2:1 FOR US ON PROFILE DSCNT. WE EXTENDED THE SPD BRAKES ALSO AT FL200. I INFORMED ATC THAT WE WERE UNABLE TO CROSS UJM AT 12000 FT, TAILWIND COMPONENT WAS 80 KTS. ZME ABRUPTLY VECTORED US OFF INBOUND RADIAL AND OFFERED REMARKS AS TO WHY WE COULDN'T CROSS IT AS EVERYONE ELSE WAS. I INFORMED HIM WE HAD DONE EVERYTHING POSSIBLE. SUPPLEMENTAL INFO FROM ACN 536747: CTLR GAVE A XING RESTR THAT REQUIRED EXCESSIVE DSCNT RATES WITH IDLE PWR, FULL SPD BRAKES AND 5000-6000 FPM RATES. WHEN WE CALLED TO TELL HIM WE WOULD MISS THE RESTR BY 2000 FT, HE BECAME ARGUMENTATIVE ABOUT WHY WE COULDN'T MAKE THE RESTR. WE INFORMED HIM ABOUT WINDS 220 DEGS, 80 KTS. PERHAPS AN EARLIER DSCNT OR USE OF THE PUBLISHED ALT RESTRS ON THE ARR WOULD HAVE PREVENTED THE DISCUSSION.

Data retrieved from NASA's ASRS site as of July 2007 and automatically converted to unabbreviated mixed upper/lowercase text. This report is for informational purposes with no guarantee of accuracy. See NASA's ASRS site for official report.