Narrative:

During climb through FL180, captain and first officer inadvertently set altimeters from 28.87 to 28.92. It wasn't until leveloff at FL299 that ATC questioned our altitude, saying we were 'indicating FL299 on his screen. Captain and first officer both quickly put altimeters to 29.92 and descended to FL290 (assigned). There was no traffic conflict. If I could recommend a change, if altimeters looked different at 29.92 from all others, error would have been caught 'at a glance.' I think there may have been distrs going through FL180 (turbulence, ice, new direct routings, frequency changes, etc). It surprises me that both captain and first officer inadvertently set 28.92 instead of 29.92. Therefore, if we were expecting a different color (or whatever) as we quickly set, or attempted to set, 29.92, then not seeing this color when we set 28.92 would have tripped something in our brains that something wasn't right.

Google
 

Original NASA ASRS Text

Title: WDB CARGO CREW MISSET THEIR ALTIMETERS 1 INCH LOW WHEN GOING THROUGH THE TRANSITION LEVEL.

Narrative: DURING CLB THROUGH FL180, CAPT AND FO INADVERTENTLY SET ALTIMETERS FROM 28.87 TO 28.92. IT WASN'T UNTIL LEVELOFF AT FL299 THAT ATC QUESTIONED OUR ALT, SAYING WE WERE 'INDICATING FL299 ON HIS SCREEN. CAPT AND FO BOTH QUICKLY PUT ALTIMETERS TO 29.92 AND DSNDED TO FL290 (ASSIGNED). THERE WAS NO TFC CONFLICT. IF I COULD RECOMMEND A CHANGE, IF ALTIMETERS LOOKED DIFFERENT AT 29.92 FROM ALL OTHERS, ERROR WOULD HAVE BEEN CAUGHT 'AT A GLANCE.' I THINK THERE MAY HAVE BEEN DISTRS GOING THROUGH FL180 (TURB, ICE, NEW DIRECT ROUTINGS, FREQ CHANGES, ETC). IT SURPRISES ME THAT BOTH CAPT AND FO INADVERTENTLY SET 28.92 INSTEAD OF 29.92. THEREFORE, IF WE WERE EXPECTING A DIFFERENT COLOR (OR WHATEVER) AS WE QUICKLY SET, OR ATTEMPTED TO SET, 29.92, THEN NOT SEEING THIS COLOR WHEN WE SET 28.92 WOULD HAVE TRIPPED SOMETHING IN OUR BRAINS THAT SOMETHING WASN'T RIGHT.

Data retrieved from NASA's ASRS site as of July 2007 and automatically converted to unabbreviated mixed upper/lowercase text. This report is for informational purposes with no guarantee of accuracy. See NASA's ASRS site for official report.