Narrative:

Boston [center] gave us crossing clearance at 12;000 ft and 250 [KTS]. We heard 11;000 ft and 250 [KTS]; set 11;000 ft; both agreed on 11;000 ft; and descended. When we questioned altitude restriction; boston [center] said 12;000 ft. [We] disengaged autopilot to arrest the descent at 11;800 ft [and the] airplane was arrested at 11;640 ft. We climbed back up to 12;000 ft. Fatigue [is an issue] because [the flight from] egcc was over 8 hours due to winds. [This] two man crew did not sleep the best due to time change in europe. This report would not have to be issued had we had a third pilot on board. This issue has been brought up many times. My fellow pilots and I agree there should be a third pilot on this trip.

Google
 

Original NASA ASRS Text

Title: A B757 descending through 12;000 FT in ZBW airspace was advised that 12;000 FT was their clearance; so they returned to that altitude. Because of winds; the two pilots had flown over 8 hours from MAN and fatigue was an issue.

Narrative: Boston [Center] gave us crossing clearance at 12;000 FT and 250 [KTS]. We heard 11;000 FT and 250 [KTS]; set 11;000 FT; both agreed on 11;000 FT; and descended. When we questioned altitude restriction; Boston [Center] said 12;000 FT. [We] disengaged autopilot to arrest the descent at 11;800 FT [and the] airplane was arrested at 11;640 FT. We climbed back up to 12;000 FT. Fatigue [is an issue] because [the flight from] EGCC was over 8 hours due to winds. [This] two man crew did not sleep the best due to time change in Europe. This report would not have to be issued had we had a third pilot on board. This issue has been brought up many times. My fellow pilots and I agree there should be a third pilot on this trip.

Data retrieved from NASA's ASRS site as of April 2012 and automatically converted to unabbreviated mixed upper/lowercase text. This report is for informational purposes with no guarantee of accuracy. See NASA's ASRS site for official report.