Narrative:

On takeoff; engine number one red egt light illuminated. [We] accomplished engine limit QRH checklist. During the climb to altitude; [we] contacted maintenance and operations with the engine data from the takeoff. Received this message from operations; 'maintenance says the aircraft will be dead upon arrival...we would like you to return to [departure airport]....change aircraft and proceed [to destination].' [we] requested clearance from ATC for diversion per company request advised the flight attendants then the passengers of our return. Landed and changed aircraft. [It] took an hour and half delay for problems generating the required paper work for our second flight. Event occurred because a previous logbook entry with the same problem was not adequately addressed by maintenance. Aircraft had a history with high egt temperatures on the engine one.

Google
 

Original NASA ASRS Text

Title: A B737-300 Captain reported high EGT on left engine during takeoff. He coordinated with Dispatch and Maintenance and returned to departure airport.

Narrative: On takeoff; engine number one red EGT light illuminated. [We] accomplished Engine Limit QRH checklist. During the climb to altitude; [we] contacted Maintenance and Operations with the engine data from the takeoff. Received this message from Operations; 'Maintenance says the aircraft will be dead upon arrival...We would like you to return to [departure airport]....Change aircraft and proceed [to destination].' [We] requested clearance from ATC for diversion per company request advised the Flight Attendants then the passengers of our return. Landed and changed aircraft. [It] took an hour and half delay for problems generating the required paper work for our second flight. Event occurred because a previous logbook entry with the same problem was not adequately addressed by maintenance. Aircraft had a history with high EGT temperatures on the engine one.

Data retrieved from NASA's ASRS site as of April 2012 and automatically converted to unabbreviated mixed upper/lowercase text. This report is for informational purposes with no guarantee of accuracy. See NASA's ASRS site for official report.