Narrative:

While working the inner low position (final controller) the outer controller (feeder position) handed off to me air carrier XXXX however air carrier XXXY took the frequency change. Air carrier XXXY checked in with me and I was expecting air carrier XXXX. On initial contact with me I over emphasized the [last digit] in the call sign after the pilot checked in calling himself air carrier XXXY. I issued air carrier XXXX a decent clearance over emphasizing the [last digit] in the call sign again. Air carrier XXXY read back the decent clearance and I restated air carrier XXXX. At that time the outer controller told me that air carrier XXXX was still on his frequency so looked at all of his traffic to see if any aircraft took an incorrect decent clearance and saw that he had a air carrier XXXY and in fact that aircraft was descending. There were no traffic conflictions and I pointed out the traffic to the cle departure position since the aircraft would be entering his airspace. The point out was approved and I kept air carrier XXXY on my frequency till he was switched to the tower on final. Continue to work with the airlines to remove similar sounding call signs. Also for me to not assume that over emphasis is enough to make sure the right aircraft received the correct clearance.

Google
 

Original NASA ASRS Text

Title: CLE Controller described an airspace incursion when an aircraft initiated a descent issued to a same company aircraft with a similar sounding four digit flight number.

Narrative: While working the Inner Low position (Final Controller) the Outer Controller (Feeder position) handed off to me Air Carrier XXXX however Air Carrier XXXY took the frequency change. Air Carrier XXXY checked in with me and I was expecting Air Carrier XXXX. On initial contact with me I over emphasized the [last digit] in the call sign after the pilot checked in calling himself Air Carrier XXXY. I issued Air Carrier XXXX a decent clearance over emphasizing the [last digit] in the call sign again. Air Carrier XXXY read back the decent clearance and I restated Air Carrier XXXX. At that time the outer controller told me that Air Carrier XXXX was still on his frequency so looked at all of his traffic to see if any aircraft took an incorrect decent clearance and saw that he had a Air Carrier XXXY and in fact that aircraft was descending. There were no traffic conflictions and I pointed out the traffic to the CLE departure position since the aircraft would be entering his airspace. The point out was approved and I kept Air Carrier XXXY on my frequency till he was switched to the Tower on final. Continue to work with the airlines to remove similar sounding call signs. Also for me to not assume that over emphasis is enough to make sure the right aircraft received the correct clearance.

Data retrieved from NASA's ASRS site as of July 2013 and automatically converted to unabbreviated mixed upper/lowercase text. This report is for informational purposes with no guarantee of accuracy. See NASA's ASRS site for official report.