Narrative:

Flight crew reported on fire detection test the 'det inoperative' light was inoperative; and APU fire t-handle light remained on after test switch released. After conference with flight crew we decided to MEL APU fire detection inoperative. APU is not used and APU fire detection circuit breaker is opened and collared. My entry into maintenance records computer did not mention the t-handle light remaining on. Apparently several flight legs later; approval was given to reset the circuit breaker and use the APU. This resulted in a false APU fire warning and blown bottle. The misunderstanding was probably the next item of MEL: 'APU det inoperative' light which allows APU operation if the fire detection operates normal. In this case; apparently the APU detection system was intermittent and tested normal for a while. I feel that adding more detail to the discrepancy; in this case; that the APU t-handle light remained on; could have prevented this error from happening.

Google
 

Original NASA ASRS Text

Title: A B737-300 ACFT FLT CREW DISCHARGED APU FIRE BOTTLE DUE TO APU FIRE 'T' HANDLE RED LIGHT CAME ON AFTER CIRCUIT BREAKER ACTIVATED. MEL DID NOT REFERENCE RED LIGHT ALWAYS 'ON.'

Narrative: FLT CREW RPTED ON FIRE DETECTION TEST THE 'DET INOP' LIGHT WAS INOP; AND APU FIRE T-HANDLE LIGHT REMAINED ON AFTER TEST SWITCH RELEASED. AFTER CONFERENCE WITH FLT CREW WE DECIDED TO MEL APU FIRE DETECTION INOP. APU IS NOT USED AND APU FIRE DETECTION CIRCUIT BREAKER IS OPENED AND COLLARED. MY ENTRY INTO MAINT RECORDS COMPUTER DID NOT MENTION THE T-HANDLE LIGHT REMAINING ON. APPARENTLY SEVERAL FLT LEGS LATER; APPROVAL WAS GIVEN TO RESET THE CIRCUIT BREAKER AND USE THE APU. THIS RESULTED IN A FALSE APU FIRE WARNING AND BLOWN BOTTLE. THE MISUNDERSTANDING WAS PROBABLY THE NEXT ITEM OF MEL: 'APU DET INOP' LIGHT WHICH ALLOWS APU OP IF THE FIRE DETECTION OPERATES NORMAL. IN THIS CASE; APPARENTLY THE APU DETECTION SYS WAS INTERMITTENT AND TESTED NORMAL FOR A WHILE. I FEEL THAT ADDING MORE DETAIL TO THE DISCREPANCY; IN THIS CASE; THAT THE APU T-HANDLE LIGHT REMAINED ON; COULD HAVE PREVENTED THIS ERROR FROM HAPPENING.

Data retrieved from NASA's ASRS site as of January 2009 and automatically converted to unabbreviated mixed upper/lowercase text. This report is for informational purposes with no guarantee of accuracy. See NASA's ASRS site for official report.