Narrative:

Falcon 50 was ready for departure and the engines were started. After a short period of time; the #2 engine computer light illuminated. The engines were shut down and a laptop was connected to the #2 engine computer. It was determined that one of the technicians mistakenly changed the engine model from TFE731-3-1C to TFE731-3D-1C. This was corrected and the engine ran to verify correct operation. The aircraft was cleared to continue in service and taxied to the end of the runway. When engine power was brought up; the #2 engine cowls opened and were caught in #1 and #3 engine jet blast. This damaged the cowls; elevators; engine afterbody; and a strobe bullet fairing. The aircraft taxied back to the ramp with #1 and #3 engines shut down. Investigation revealed that the #2 engine cowl had been opened during troubleshooting and had not been properly latched. I believe this happened due to self imposed pressure to return the aircraft to service as soon as possible. The technicians and pilots missed the latches not being properly locked in the closed position.callback conversation with reporter revealed the following information: the reporter stated that the cowling latches on all three engines have always been a problem due to no positive indication the latches are locked; adding the #2 engine cowling is hinged at the top and the three latches are located on the bottom centerline. Reportedly; when the latches are locked; or false locked; a circular latch button slightly larger than a quarter is flush with the cowling surface. The reporter indicated with the latches unlocked; this large button protrudes .750 to 1 inch below the cowling surface but in this event the latch buttons were painted the same color as the airplane lower surface and difficult to observe.supplemental information from acn 684616: on departure aircraft had a engine computer light on #2 engine. Aircraft was pulled back into hangar and repaired computer fault. Aircraft was pushed back; loaded crew and passenger; started engines and taxied out. Crew called on radio and reported loud banging sound in rear of aircraft. Taxied back to hangar and found #2 engine cowling had not been locked and damaged cowling from jet blast of #1 and #3 engines.callback conversation with reporter 684616 revealed the following information: the reporter stated that the latches were either false latched or not latched correctly. The reporter stated there is not enough latch extension when unlocked to determine if the cowling is locked unless standing directly under the latch. The reporter indicated events of #2 cowlings opening with jet blast from #1 and #3 engine has happened before at this station and caused extensive damage to the airplane. Supplemental information from acn 684414: falcon 50 was on the ramp with passenger on board when the fault on the #2 engine was detected by the crew. A deec download was performed and fault codes were found. One of the codes indicated that the engine P/north and type stored in the deec was incorrect. The #2 engine cowlings were then opened to get the P/north off the engine data plate. After corrections were made to the deec programming; the aircraft was backed out of the hangar and the #2 engine was started to verify that the fault had been corrected. The aircraft was then released to the crew. When the #1 and #3 engines were taken to power prior to takeoff; the #2 engine cowlings were caught in the jet blast; causing damage to the aircraft. The engine cowlings had not been latched after they were opened. To correct this problem in the future; a final walk around inspection will be performed before the aircraft is released from maintenance.callback conversation with reporter revealed the following information: the reporter stated the latch buttons are difficult to see if unlocked being painted the same color of the lower fuselage. Reporter noted that the manufacturer issued a service advisory with an illustration of two latch buttons that were flush with the lower surface of the cowling but were false latched. The reporter indicated that this cowling separated from this airplane.supplemental information from acn 684905: this incident involving the #2 engine cowls has occurred to other operators and maintenance facilities as well.

Google
 

Original NASA ASRS Text

Title: WHEN THE ENG WAS BROUGHT UP TO TKOF POWER ON A FA50; THE #2 ENG COWLING OPENED; DAMAGING COWLING; ELEVATORS; AND ENG AFTERBODY. RPTRS NOTE LATCH DESIGN CONTRIBUTED TO THE INCIDENT.

Narrative: FALCON 50 WAS READY FOR DEP AND THE ENGS WERE STARTED. AFTER A SHORT PERIOD OF TIME; THE #2 ENG COMPUTER LIGHT ILLUMINATED. THE ENGS WERE SHUT DOWN AND A LAPTOP WAS CONNECTED TO THE #2 ENG COMPUTER. IT WAS DETERMINED THAT ONE OF THE TECHNICIANS MISTAKENLY CHANGED THE ENG MODEL FROM TFE731-3-1C TO TFE731-3D-1C. THIS WAS CORRECTED AND THE ENG RAN TO VERIFY CORRECT OPERATION. THE ACFT WAS CLRED TO CONTINUE IN SVC AND TAXIED TO THE END OF THE RWY. WHEN ENG POWER WAS BROUGHT UP; THE #2 ENG COWLS OPENED AND WERE CAUGHT IN #1 AND #3 ENG JET BLAST. THIS DAMAGED THE COWLS; ELEVATORS; ENG AFTERBODY; AND A STROBE BULLET FAIRING. THE ACFT TAXIED BACK TO THE RAMP WITH #1 AND #3 ENGS SHUT DOWN. INVESTIGATION REVEALED THAT THE #2 ENG COWL HAD BEEN OPENED DURING TROUBLESHOOTING AND HAD NOT BEEN PROPERLY LATCHED. I BELIEVE THIS HAPPENED DUE TO SELF IMPOSED PRESSURE TO RETURN THE ACFT TO SVC AS SOON AS POSSIBLE. THE TECHNICIANS AND PLTS MISSED THE LATCHES NOT BEING PROPERLY LOCKED IN THE CLOSED POSITION.CALLBACK CONVERSATION WITH RPTR REVEALED THE FOLLOWING INFO: THE RPTR STATED THAT THE COWLING LATCHES ON ALL THREE ENGS HAVE ALWAYS BEEN A PROBLEM DUE TO NO POSITIVE INDICATION THE LATCHES ARE LOCKED; ADDING THE #2 ENG COWLING IS HINGED AT THE TOP AND THE THREE LATCHES ARE LOCATED ON THE BOTTOM CTRLINE. REPORTEDLY; WHEN THE LATCHES ARE LOCKED; OR FALSE LOCKED; A CIRCULAR LATCH BUTTON SLIGHTLY LARGER THAN A QUARTER IS FLUSH WITH THE COWLING SURFACE. THE RPTR INDICATED WITH THE LATCHES UNLOCKED; THIS LARGE BUTTON PROTRUDES .750 TO 1 INCH BELOW THE COWLING SURFACE BUT IN THIS EVENT THE LATCH BUTTONS WERE PAINTED THE SAME COLOR AS THE AIRPLANE LOWER SURFACE AND DIFFICULT TO OBSERVE.SUPPLEMENTAL INFO FROM ACN 684616: ON DEP ACFT HAD A ENG COMPUTER LIGHT ON #2 ENG. ACFT WAS PULLED BACK INTO HANGAR AND REPAIRED COMPUTER FAULT. ACFT WAS PUSHED BACK; LOADED CREW AND PAX; STARTED ENGS AND TAXIED OUT. CREW CALLED ON RADIO AND REPORTED LOUD BANGING SOUND IN REAR OF ACFT. TAXIED BACK TO HANGAR AND FOUND #2 ENG COWLING HAD NOT BEEN LOCKED AND DAMAGED COWLING FROM JET BLAST OF #1 AND #3 ENGS.CALLBACK CONVERSATION WITH RPTR 684616 REVEALED THE FOLLOWING INFO: THE RPTR STATED THAT THE LATCHES WERE EITHER FALSE LATCHED OR NOT LATCHED CORRECTLY. THE RPTR STATED THERE IS NOT ENOUGH LATCH EXTENSION WHEN UNLOCKED TO DETERMINE IF THE COWLING IS LOCKED UNLESS STANDING DIRECTLY UNDER THE LATCH. THE RPTR INDICATED EVENTS OF #2 COWLINGS OPENING WITH JET BLAST FROM #1 AND #3 ENG HAS HAPPENED BEFORE AT THIS STATION AND CAUSED EXTENSIVE DAMAGE TO THE AIRPLANE. SUPPLEMENTAL INFO FROM ACN 684414: FALCON 50 WAS ON THE RAMP WITH PAX ON BOARD WHEN THE FAULT ON THE #2 ENG WAS DETECTED BY THE CREW. A DEEC DOWNLOAD WAS PERFORMED AND FAULT CODES WERE FOUND. ONE OF THE CODES INDICATED THAT THE ENG P/N AND TYPE STORED IN THE DEEC WAS INCORRECT. THE #2 ENG COWLINGS WERE THEN OPENED TO GET THE P/N OFF THE ENG DATA PLATE. AFTER CORRECTIONS WERE MADE TO THE DEEC PROGRAMMING; THE ACFT WAS BACKED OUT OF THE HANGAR AND THE #2 ENG WAS STARTED TO VERIFY THAT THE FAULT HAD BEEN CORRECTED. THE ACFT WAS THEN RELEASED TO THE CREW. WHEN THE #1 AND #3 ENGS WERE TAKEN TO POWER PRIOR TO TKOF; THE #2 ENG COWLINGS WERE CAUGHT IN THE JET BLAST; CAUSING DAMAGE TO THE ACFT. THE ENG COWLINGS HAD NOT BEEN LATCHED AFTER THEY WERE OPENED. TO CORRECT THIS PROBLEM IN THE FUTURE; A FINAL WALK AROUND INSPECTION WILL BE PERFORMED BEFORE THE ACFT IS RELEASED FROM MAINT.CALLBACK CONVERSATION WITH RPTR REVEALED THE FOLLOWING INFO: THE RPTR STATED THE LATCH BUTTONS ARE DIFFICULT TO SEE IF UNLOCKED BEING PAINTED THE SAME COLOR OF THE LOWER FUSELAGE. RPTR NOTED THAT THE MANUFACTURER ISSUED A SVC ADVISORY WITH AN ILLUSTRATION OF TWO LATCH BUTTONS THAT WERE FLUSH WITH THE LOWER SURFACE OF THE COWLING BUT WERE FALSE LATCHED. THE RPTR INDICATED THAT THIS COWLING SEPARATED FROM THIS AIRPLANE.SUPPLEMENTAL INFO FROM ACN 684905: THIS INCIDENT INVOLVING THE #2 ENG COWLS HAS OCCURRED TO OTHER OPERATORS AND MAINT FACILITIES AS WELL.

Data retrieved from NASA's ASRS site as of January 2009 and automatically converted to unabbreviated mixed upper/lowercase text. This report is for informational purposes with no guarantee of accuracy. See NASA's ASRS site for official report.