Narrative:

I lowered the landing gear at 130 KTS while on downwind to runway 24 at ZZZ. The sound made when the gear lowered was more of a pop than the usual clunk. The sound was not out of the ordinary enough to raise a red flag though and I had 3 green lights. I continued the approach to what should have been a very normal landing only to find there was no nose gear. The aircraft skidded on the nose for 1000-1500 ft. I only lightly applied right and left braking for directional control. I felt heavy braking could aggravate an already bad situation. Upon inspection of the aircraft we found the nose gear v-brace was broken in half just below the pivot point on the right side. The tube coming from the gearbox connects to the v-brace 6 inches above where the v-brace broke. This allowed just the upper right portion of the v-brace to pivot in turn closing the limit switch for the gear down and locked light. The brace broke through a factory drilled hole used to add a rust inhibitor inside the tube. The wall of the broken tube was rusted 3/4 of the way around indicating the tube had been cracked for a long time. I feel this is an area on all the older barons and bonanza that should have a closer than normal inspection. Callback conversation with reporter revealed the following information: the reporter stated when the landing gear was selected to down heard a different sound but was not alarmed. The reporter said the 'V' brace failed just below the landing gear operations sensor so the nose gear indication was green. The reporter believes all older barons and bonanza aircraft should have an intensified inspection of this hollow 'V' brace.

Google
 

Original NASA ASRS Text

Title: A BEECH 58TC WITH 3 GREEN LIGHTS LANDED WITH THE NOSE GEAR RETRACTED. CAUSED BY A BROKEN 'V' BRACE. BREAK OCCURRED BELOW GEAR POS SENSOR.

Narrative: I LOWERED THE LNDG GEAR AT 130 KTS WHILE ON DOWNWIND TO RWY 24 AT ZZZ. THE SOUND MADE WHEN THE GEAR LOWERED WAS MORE OF A POP THAN THE USUAL CLUNK. THE SOUND WAS NOT OUT OF THE ORDINARY ENOUGH TO RAISE A RED FLAG THOUGH AND I HAD 3 GREEN LIGHTS. I CONTINUED THE APCH TO WHAT SHOULD HAVE BEEN A VERY NORMAL LNDG ONLY TO FIND THERE WAS NO NOSE GEAR. THE ACFT SKIDDED ON THE NOSE FOR 1000-1500 FT. I ONLY LIGHTLY APPLIED R AND L BRAKING FOR DIRECTIONAL CTL. I FELT HVY BRAKING COULD AGGRAVATE AN ALREADY BAD SIT. UPON INSPECTION OF THE ACFT WE FOUND THE NOSE GEAR V-BRACE WAS BROKEN IN HALF JUST BELOW THE PIVOT POINT ON THE R SIDE. THE TUBE COMING FROM THE GEARBOX CONNECTS TO THE V-BRACE 6 INCHES ABOVE WHERE THE V-BRACE BROKE. THIS ALLOWED JUST THE UPPER R PORTION OF THE V-BRACE TO PIVOT IN TURN CLOSING THE LIMIT SWITCH FOR THE GEAR DOWN AND LOCKED LIGHT. THE BRACE BROKE THROUGH A FACTORY DRILLED HOLE USED TO ADD A RUST INHIBITOR INSIDE THE TUBE. THE WALL OF THE BROKEN TUBE WAS RUSTED 3/4 OF THE WAY AROUND INDICATING THE TUBE HAD BEEN CRACKED FOR A LONG TIME. I FEEL THIS IS AN AREA ON ALL THE OLDER BARONS AND BONANZA THAT SHOULD HAVE A CLOSER THAN NORMAL INSPECTION. CALLBACK CONVERSATION WITH RPTR REVEALED THE FOLLOWING INFO: THE RPTR STATED WHEN THE LNDG GEAR WAS SELECTED TO DOWN HEARD A DIFFERENT SOUND BUT WAS NOT ALARMED. THE RPTR SAID THE 'V' BRACE FAILED JUST BELOW THE LNDG GEAR OPS SENSOR SO THE NOSE GEAR INDICATION WAS GREEN. THE RPTR BELIEVES ALL OLDER BARONS AND BONANZA ACFT SHOULD HAVE AN INTENSIFIED INSPECTION OF THIS HOLLOW 'V' BRACE.

Data retrieved from NASA's ASRS site as of July 2007 and automatically converted to unabbreviated mixed upper/lowercase text. This report is for informational purposes with no guarantee of accuracy. See NASA's ASRS site for official report.