Narrative:

Aircraft was inspected by FAA (ride along inspector) who felt that more than 40 odd solid rivets at 2 locations were in need of replacement. Location was at #2 engine inboard cowl door 6 rivets total, two of which were replaced. 35 odd rivets were idented as bad at leading edge of #1 air conditioning air inlet, only one of which was replaced. All other rivets were inspected and found sound per srm 51-30-02. It is my belief that this item could have been resolved by MEL/deferral instead of grounding the aircraft and causing unnecessary passenger/delay and direct and serious cost to the company. This FAA inspector clearly needs to be further educated on his job and the structural repair manual. He is, by his actions, detracting from the FAA stated mission of safety by showing his total lack of experience.

Google
 

Original NASA ASRS Text

Title: A B737-200 WAS GROUNDED AFTER A SAFETY INSPECTION BY AN FAA SAFETY INSPECTOR LOOKING AT RIVETS. 40 RIVETS WRITTEN UP AS NEEDING REPLACEMENT.

Narrative: ACFT WAS INSPECTED BY FAA (RIDE ALONG INSPECTOR) WHO FELT THAT MORE THAN 40 ODD SOLID RIVETS AT 2 LOCATIONS WERE IN NEED OF REPLACEMENT. LOCATION WAS AT #2 ENG INBOARD COWL DOOR 6 RIVETS TOTAL, TWO OF WHICH WERE REPLACED. 35 ODD RIVETS WERE IDENTED AS BAD AT LEADING EDGE OF #1 AIR CONDITIONING AIR INLET, ONLY ONE OF WHICH WAS REPLACED. ALL OTHER RIVETS WERE INSPECTED AND FOUND SOUND PER SRM 51-30-02. IT IS MY BELIEF THAT THIS ITEM COULD HAVE BEEN RESOLVED BY MEL/DEFERRAL INSTEAD OF GROUNDING THE ACFT AND CAUSING UNNECESSARY PAX/DELAY AND DIRECT AND SERIOUS COST TO THE COMPANY. THIS FAA INSPECTOR CLRLY NEEDS TO BE FURTHER EDUCATED ON HIS JOB AND THE STRUCTURAL REPAIR MANUAL. HE IS, BY HIS ACTIONS, DETRACTING FROM THE FAA STATED MISSION OF SAFETY BY SHOWING HIS TOTAL LACK OF EXPERIENCE.

Data retrieved from NASA's ASRS site as of July 2007 and automatically converted to unabbreviated mixed upper/lowercase text. This report is for informational purposes with no guarantee of accuracy. See NASA's ASRS site for official report.