Narrative:

During preflight, a 'MEL' item, aft cargo door, was discussed by crew and maintenance. The activator was weak and required manual cranking (2 turns) to flush door and handle. This agreed with MEL and external preflight. Confirmed (through viewing ports) that overlocks were in place and overctr. Shortly after takeoff 'cargo door-aft' illuminated. Aircraft was still unpressurized (which is normal) and was left unpressurized. Cockpit operated manual references -- do not pressurize, which of course required return to department airport (hkg). Takeoff weight 713000 pounds, maximum landing 630000 pounds, so dumping of fuel was commenced at 8000 ft MSL with hkg department concurrence. Landing normal. Maintenance that night replaced the 'aft-cargo door' actuator and all closed switches. The next morning's flight event without a hitch. Expensive lesson on fixing things right the first time. Aircraft was overnight with 15 hours time to fix original problem.

Google
 

Original NASA ASRS Text

Title: WDB CARGO ACFT HAS CARGO DOOR LIGHT ILLUMINATE AFTER TKOF.

Narrative: DURING PREFLT, A 'MEL' ITEM, AFT CARGO DOOR, WAS DISCUSSED BY CREW AND MAINT. THE ACTIVATOR WAS WEAK AND REQUIRED MANUAL CRANKING (2 TURNS) TO FLUSH DOOR AND HANDLE. THIS AGREED WITH MEL AND EXTERNAL PREFLT. CONFIRMED (THROUGH VIEWING PORTS) THAT OVERLOCKS WERE IN PLACE AND OVERCTR. SHORTLY AFTER TKOF 'CARGO DOOR-AFT' ILLUMINATED. ACFT WAS STILL UNPRESSURIZED (WHICH IS NORMAL) AND WAS LEFT UNPRESSURIZED. COCKPIT OPERATED MANUAL REFERENCES -- DO NOT PRESSURIZE, WHICH OF COURSE REQUIRED RETURN TO DEPT ARPT (HKG). TKOF WT 713000 LBS, MAX LNDG 630000 LBS, SO DUMPING OF FUEL WAS COMMENCED AT 8000 FT MSL WITH HKG DEPT CONCURRENCE. LNDG NORMAL. MAINT THAT NIGHT REPLACED THE 'AFT-CARGO DOOR' ACTUATOR AND ALL CLOSED SWITCHES. THE NEXT MORNING'S FLT EVENT WITHOUT A HITCH. EXPENSIVE LESSON ON FIXING THINGS RIGHT THE FIRST TIME. ACFT WAS OVERNIGHT WITH 15 HRS TIME TO FIX ORIGINAL PROB.

Data retrieved from NASA's ASRS site as of July 2007 and automatically converted to unabbreviated mixed upper/lowercase text. This report is for informational purposes with no guarantee of accuracy. See NASA's ASRS site for official report.