Narrative:

I climbed air carrier X flight abbb to 36;000 feet. I believe air carrier X flight aabb took the clearance and I did not realize it. I also believe that they both took the clearance but I'm not sure. Moments later I switched flight aabb frequency via cpdlc. While flight abbb was climbing into my sector I noticed that flight aabb started descending. I was not talking to flight aabb. I verbally coordinated with the sector which is located next to me that I'm stopping flight abbb at 35;000 feet and turning south and then I issued the instruction to the pilot. Then the sector I gave flight aabb to called and said that flight aabb was returning to 38;000 feet. When traffic was no longer a factor I climbed flight abbb to 36;000 feet and turned them on course. I never realized how close the call signs were until it was too late. Be more aware of similar call signs.

Google
 

Original NASA ASRS Text

Title: ZID ARTCC Controller reported the wrong aircraft acknowledged for a new altitude assignment and the Controller did not detect it due to similar sounding call signs.

Narrative: I climbed Air Carrier X Flight ABBB to 36;000 feet. I believe Air Carrier X Flight AABB took the clearance and I did not realize it. I also believe that they both took the clearance but I'm not sure. Moments later I switched Flight AABB frequency via CPDLC. While Flight ABBB was climbing into my sector I noticed that Flight AABB started descending. I was not talking to Flight AABB. I verbally coordinated with the sector which is located next to me that I'm stopping Flight ABBB at 35;000 feet and turning south and then I issued the instruction to the pilot. Then the sector I gave Flight AABB to called and said that Flight AABB was returning to 38;000 feet. When traffic was no longer a factor I climbed Flight ABBB to 36;000 feet and turned them on course. I never realized how close the call signs were until it was too late. Be more aware of similar call signs.

Data retrieved from NASA's ASRS site and automatically converted to unabbreviated mixed upper/lowercase text. This report is for informational purposes with no guarantee of accuracy. See NASA's ASRS site for official report.