Narrative:

We were cleared direct nrrli on the serfr 3. I line selected narwl; brought it to the top of the legs page; and confirmed with the captain 'looks good?' he replied 'looks good.' a while later; approximately 10 miles south/southeast of point nrrli; ATC asked 'are you direct nrrli?' the captain replied 'affirm; direct narrli.' we then both reviewed the STAR and the captain noticed point nrrli. We then reloaded the STAR and headed directly towards nrrli. Once we executed the direct nrrli; the aircraft turned approximately 10-20 degrees from our previous heading to narwl. Nothing more was said from ATC; the rest of the flight was uneventful.

Google
 

Original NASA ASRS Text

Title: Air carrier flight crew on arrival to SFO airport reported navigating to the wrong fix due to similar sounding names NARWL AND NRRLI.

Narrative: We were cleared direct NRRLI on the SERFR 3. I line selected NARWL; brought it to the top of the LEGS page; and confirmed with the Captain 'looks good?' He replied 'looks good.' A while later; approximately 10 miles south/southeast of point NRRLI; ATC asked 'are you direct NRRLI?' The Captain replied 'affirm; direct NARRLI.' We then both reviewed the STAR and the Captain noticed point NRRLI. We then reloaded the STAR and headed directly towards NRRLI. Once we executed the direct NRRLI; the aircraft turned approximately 10-20 degrees from our previous heading to NARWL. Nothing more was said from ATC; the rest of the flight was uneventful.

Data retrieved from NASA's ASRS site and automatically converted to unabbreviated mixed upper/lowercase text. This report is for informational purposes with no guarantee of accuracy. See NASA's ASRS site for official report.