Narrative:

Leveling at 2;700 MSL cleared for ILS runway 27 cid. ATC issued a low altitude alert and while our altimeter indicated that we were 300' above the cleared altitude; we executed an immediate go around and commenced a climb to the ATC issued altitude of 3;000 MSL. Upon level off; we realized that the altimeters had been incorrectly set during the descent check. We obtained the correct local altimeter setting from ATC and returned to the desired aircraft state. We returned for another ILS to runway 27 at cid and landed uneventfully. The probable cause was that the altimeter was set incorrectly do to confusion with an ATC received altimeter setting and failure to verify the correct setting. During the pre-descent ATIS check both crew members wrote the correct altimeter setting. During the descent we set the altimeter according to an ATC issued altimeter setting which we both believe we heard correctly.

Google
 

Original NASA ASRS Text

Title: Medium Large transport flight crew reported receiving a low altitude alert from ATC on the approach to CID. They discovered they had the wrong altimeter setting entered.

Narrative: Leveling at 2;700 MSL cleared for ILS Runway 27 CID. ATC issued a low altitude alert and while our altimeter indicated that we were 300' above the cleared altitude; we executed an immediate go around and commenced a climb to the ATC issued altitude of 3;000 MSL. Upon level off; we realized that the altimeters had been incorrectly set during the descent check. We obtained the correct local altimeter setting from ATC and returned to the desired aircraft state. We returned for another ILS to Runway 27 at CID and landed uneventfully. The probable cause was that the altimeter was set incorrectly do to confusion with an ATC received altimeter setting and failure to verify the correct setting. During the pre-descent ATIS check both crew members wrote the correct altimeter setting. During the descent we set the altimeter according to an ATC issued altimeter setting which we both believe we heard correctly.

Data retrieved from NASA's ASRS site and automatically converted to unabbreviated mixed upper/lowercase text. This report is for informational purposes with no guarantee of accuracy. See NASA's ASRS site for official report.