Narrative:

From a cruising altitude of FL260; toronto center issued a clearance 'descend to FL240; descend via the NUBER2 arrival.' we immediately started down to FL240; and continued our descent via the arrival procedure. Passing through FL230; the controller asked what altitude we were going to. We explained we were descending via the arrival; to cross rokto between 14;000 and 12;000. The controller explained that the newly adopted 'descend via' phraseology in canada does not allow us to descend below a given altitude. After multiple inquiries; we were finally able to understand that the intention of the clearance is to descend to the given altitude and comply with the arrival restrictions. He said there has been a lot of confusion in the first week of these new clearances; and didn't seem concerned.the 'descend via' clearance is used differently in the united states and canada; so crews should be sure to verify with canadian controllers what is expected of them. Unlike the united states; a descend via clearance in canada does not allow a descent all the way to the lowest altitude; but the specific assigned altitude.

Google
 

Original NASA ASRS Text

Title: Hawker 800 First Officer reported an altitude deviation occurred that arose from the difference in 'descend via' clearances between Canada and the United States.

Narrative: From a cruising altitude of FL260; Toronto Center issued a clearance 'Descend to FL240; descend via the NUBER2 arrival.' We immediately started down to FL240; and continued our descent via the arrival procedure. Passing through FL230; the Controller asked what altitude we were going to. We explained we were descending via the arrival; to cross ROKTO between 14;000 and 12;000. The Controller explained that the newly adopted 'descend via' phraseology in Canada does not allow us to descend below a given altitude. After multiple inquiries; we were finally able to understand that the intention of the clearance is to descend to the given altitude and comply with the arrival restrictions. He said there has been a lot of confusion in the first week of these new clearances; and didn't seem concerned.The 'descend via' clearance is used differently in the United States and Canada; so crews should be sure to verify with Canadian controllers what is expected of them. Unlike the United States; a descend via clearance in Canada does not allow a descent all the way to the lowest altitude; but the specific assigned altitude.

Data retrieved from NASA's ASRS site and automatically converted to unabbreviated mixed upper/lowercase text. This report is for informational purposes with no guarantee of accuracy. See NASA's ASRS site for official report.