Narrative:

I was working R76 as the radar and issued the A319 at FL380 a clearance direct filbe and cross 20 miles north of filbe at FL360. The pilot read back all of it and then stopped and said repeat the altitude. So I reissued the whole clearance again very slowly. The pilot read back the entire clearance with his call sign with the correct altitude of FL360. However 5 mins later a B737 level at FL350 was converging within 3-5 miles with the A319. A merging target call was not required based on the targets. So the A319 vacated FL380 to meet his crossing restriction. He continued descending beyond FL360 and the next controller questioned the pilot and he stated he had worked it out with me and that I had given him FL260. But this is incorrect as I reviewed the audio tapes. The relieving controller amended the altitude to FL340 and coordinated with R58 st. Augustine. The loss of separation was 4.9 miles and 600 feet. This was a pilot deviation. No further issues occurred.the relieving controller could have issued a merging target call even though the targets did not merge. But an added safety net when aircraft are within 3-5 miles and descending or climbing is a good practice.

Google
 

Original NASA ASRS Text

Title: A319 flight crew and the Controller involved describe a misunderstanding of a crossing restriction assignment; even after the controller repeated it twice.

Narrative: I was working R76 as the Radar and issued the A319 at FL380 a clearance direct FILBE and cross 20 miles north of FILBE at FL360. The pilot read back all of it and then stopped and said repeat the altitude. So I reissued the whole clearance again very slowly. The pilot read back the entire clearance with his call sign with the correct altitude of FL360. However 5 mins later a B737 level at FL350 was converging within 3-5 miles with the A319. A merging target call was not required based on the targets. So the A319 vacated FL380 to meet his crossing restriction. He continued descending beyond FL360 and the next controller questioned the pilot and he stated he had worked it out with me and that I had given him FL260. But this is incorrect as I reviewed the audio tapes. The relieving controller amended the altitude to FL340 and coordinated with R58 St. Augustine. The Loss of Separation was 4.9 miles and 600 feet. This was a pilot deviation. No further issues occurred.The relieving controller could have issued a merging target call even though the targets did not merge. But an added safety net when aircraft are within 3-5 miles and descending or climbing is a good practice.

Data retrieved from NASA's ASRS site and automatically converted to unabbreviated mixed upper/lowercase text. This report is for informational purposes with no guarantee of accuracy. See NASA's ASRS site for official report.