Narrative:

After advising the controller of airport in sight and cancelling IFR flight plan; controller requested to squawk 1200 VFR code. We made a visual approach and landing to what we thought was odo airport. It was not until we had safely landed without any incident to anyone; that we realized that we had landed at maf instead of odo. At the time of our landing midland airport tower was closed. The flight was a 3:30 hour flight. We had left our hotel at XA00 local time for a XD00 departure however; the passengers showed up 2 hours late. It is my belief that fatigue was a contributing factor; as well as; accepting a visual in a non-familiar airport at night. Both airports have similar runway alignment and are within a close proximity to each other (odo rwy 34 and rwy 29) (maf rwy 34 and rwy 28). In the future when landing in a non-familiar airport day or night; I will not take a visual approach; instead; I will remain on instruments until positive identification of correct airport has been made or I will allow the controller to vector me to final.

Google
 

Original NASA ASRS Text

Title: CE500 Flight Crew on an IFR flight to ODO; late at night; reports canceling IFR and accepting a visual approach. After landing they discover they have landed at MAF.

Narrative: After advising the Controller of airport in sight and cancelling IFR flight plan; Controller requested to squawk 1200 VFR code. We made a visual approach and landing to what we thought was ODO airport. It was not until we had safely landed without any incident to anyone; that we realized that we had landed at MAF instead of ODO. At the time of our landing Midland Airport Tower was closed. The flight was a 3:30 hour flight. We had left our hotel at XA00 local time for a XD00 departure however; the passengers showed up 2 hours late. It is my belief that fatigue was a contributing factor; as well as; accepting a visual in a non-familiar airport at night. Both airports have similar runway alignment and are within a close proximity to each other (ODO Rwy 34 and Rwy 29) (MAF Rwy 34 and Rwy 28). In the future when landing in a non-familiar airport day or night; I will not take a visual approach; instead; I will remain on instruments until positive identification of correct airport has been made or I will allow the controller to vector me to final.

Data retrieved from NASA's ASRS site and automatically converted to unabbreviated mixed upper/lowercase text. This report is for informational purposes with no guarantee of accuracy. See NASA's ASRS site for official report.